Whether or not they would have dated in high school is irrelevant. The question is: what the hell happened to Evan Rachel Wood between the time that photo was taken and today? Also, technically, wasn't she in high school and dating Marilyn Manson?
[Source]

Who DIDN'T know Manson was a nerd in high school??
Manson is actually kind of . . . cute? . . . in this pic.
Who is this Mo Rocca character, and why is he a comedian if he's not funny?
If I were Evan Rachel Wood's parents, I'd lock her away until Marilyn Manson self destructed. No way would I want my daughter bringing home that for Sunday dinner.
Brian Warner was indeed not loved enough. But I agree with Other Karen: he's kinda cute in this pic. He's got an Ike Eisenmann thing going on.
Man, Owen Wilson was my kinda heartbreak in high school! What a cutie…today…not so much.
That is not a picture of ERW in high school anyway. She is probably in 7th grade there, and she looks sad. Poor little girl. Her dad should kick Manson's ass.